35 Homes for Sale in Shinnecock Hills

1 of 33

Shinnecock Hills

542 Montauk

Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

3 Bd1 Ba

Single Family

$1,495,000

Listed:6/28/2024$1,495,000

date	Price	variance	type
6/28/2024	$1,495,000	--	Listed

1 of 34

Shinnecock Hills

7 Middle Pond Lane

Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

3 Bd2 Ba1,820 SF

Single Family

$2,695,000

$1,481/SF

Listing by: Compass

Listed:6/27/2024$2,695,000

date	Price	variance	type
6/27/2024	$2,695,000	--	Listed

1 of 33

Shinnecock Hills

14 Landing Lane

Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

2 Bd2 Ba1,500 SF

Single Family

$1,520,000

$1,013/SF

Listing by: Saunders & Associates

Listed:6/18/2024$1,520,000

date	Price	variance	type
6/18/2024	$1,520,000	--	Listed

1 of 35

Shinnecock Hills

36 Blackwatch

Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

4 Bd3 Ba

Single Family

$2,950,000

Listing by: Nest Seekers International LLC

decreased:9/7/2024$2,950,000(1.50%)

date	Price	variance	type
9/7/2024	$2,950,000	-1.50%	decreased
6/13/2024	$2,995,000	--	Listed

1 of 2

Shinnecock Hills

15 Oceanview Drive

Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

Land

$2,100,000

Listing by: Coldwell Banker Reliable R E

Listed:5/10/2024$2,100,000

date	Price	variance	type
5/10/2024	$2,100,000	--	Listed

1 of 5

Contract 06-12-24

Shinnecock Hills

45 & 59 Shinnecock Hills Road

45 & 59 Shinnecock Hills Road, Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

Land

$750,000

Listing by: Signature Premier Properties

Contract:6/12/2024$750,000

date	Price	variance	type
6/12/2024	$750,000	--	Contract

1 of 11

Shinnecock Hills

85 Eastway Drive

Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

Land

$1,100,000

Listing by: Coldwell Banker Reliable R E

Listed:3/11/2024$1,100,000

date	Price	variance	type
3/11/2024	$1,100,000	--	Listed

1 of 36

Shinnecock Hills

51 Arbutus Road

Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

7 Bd7 Ba

Single Family

$3,695,000

Listing by: Nest Seekers International LLC

decreased:11/23/2024$3,695,000(13.97%)

date	Price	variance	type
11/23/2024	$3,695,000	-13.97%	decreased
9/18/2024	$4,295,000	-4.45%	decreased
2/7/2024	$4,495,000	--	Listed

1 of 25

Shinnecock Hills

8 Middle Pond Lane

Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

5 Bd5 Ba4,000 SF

Single Family

$3,995,000

$999/SF

Listing by: Saunders & Associates

Listed:10/3/2023$3,995,000

date	Price	variance	type
10/3/2023	$3,995,000	--	Listed

1 of 36

Shinnecock Hills

207 & 209 Parrish Pond Court West

207 & 209 Parrish Pond Court West, Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

6 Bd7 Ba6,015 SF

Single Family

$7,600,000

$1,264/SF

Listing by: Compass

decreased:10/27/2024$7,600,000(5.00%)

date	Price	variance	type
10/27/2024	$7,600,000	-5.00%	decreased
9/11/2023	$7,999,999	--	Listed

1 of 36

Shinnecock Hills

354 Saint Andrews Road

Shinnecock Hills, Southampton, NY 11968

7 Bd7 Ba5,800 SF

Single Family

$3,595,000

$620/SF

Listing by: Nest Seekers International LLC

Listed:6/14/2024$3,595,000

date	Price	variance	type
6/14/2024	$3,595,000	--	Listed

All information is from sources deemed reliable but is subject to errors, omissions, changes in price, prior sale or withdrawal without notice. No representation is made as to the accuracy of any descriptions, measurements, square footages or acreage and should not be relied upon as such. All information herein should be confirmed by the customer. All rights to all content, including but not limited to photographs, videos and other graphics, are reserved to exclusively to the Broker who supplied such listing content. All advertising on this site is subject to the Federal Fair Housing Act.